I received another version of the assignment yesterday to have a read of. This version, like my other colleague, found that both items were chattels and could be removed.

Have I on that basis changed my mind? Absolutely not. To my mind their arguments do not stay on point to the specific details that form the basis of the legal question. They both drift off into arguments that while they have merit are not focused on the specific question in relation to the law.

After the assignment is marked I’ll put up all the details and the arguments put forward.